Skip to main content

Octagonal Numbers and Negative Number Bases

 Again to recap, the first five 2-digit self generating numbers in their corresponding number bases are listed below. And because they are 2-digit, linear and circular definitions coincide: likewise hierarchical and non-hierarchical distinctions do not apply.

  base 2

  base 5

   base 8

   base 11

   base 14

     01

    13

      25

      37

       49

Now, when we convert these five numbers to our customary base 10, i.e. 1, 8, 21, 40, 65, an interesting pattern emerges as these represent the corresponding terms in the well-known octagonal series for n = 1 to 5 (inclusive) where

Tn = 3n2 – 2n.

And this pattern continues to hold for all 2-digit self generating numbers in the corresponding number bases (np – 1) for positive integer values of n.

So for example when n = 6, the corresponding 2-digit number is 5B in base 17.

And when this number is converted to base 10, we obtain 96, which is the octagonal number (Tn) for n = 6. (For a fuller listing of these numbers see A000567 in the OEIS).

So the octagonal numbers have - perhaps - an important unexpected link with all 2-digit generating numbers (where linear and circular sequences coincide). They equally bear an important link with the unique decimal number sequences of the reciprocal of 3 i.e. 1/3 (in the corresponding number bases where these result in cyclic numbers).


So far we have looked at these 2-digit self-generating numbers for positive terms in their corresponding positive number bases.

However the octagonal numbers can equally be given coherent integer values where

n = 0, – 1, – 2, – 3, – 4, …

i.e. 0, 5, 16, 33, 56, …

The table below then shows the first few octagonal numbers for both positive and negative values of n.

…

n = – 4

n = – 3

n = – 2

n = – 1

n = 0

n = 1

n = 2

n = 3

n = 4

…

…

56

33

16

5

0

1

8

21

40

…

The fascinating question then arises as to how the 2-digit self-generating numbers, that we have already linked up with corresponding octagonal numbers for positive number bases (and positive values of n) can be equally extended to negative number bases (and negative values of n).

The clue to this lies in a regular pattern that always connects cyclic numbers as we move into successively higher number bases.

To illustrate here we will start by referring to the best known of the cyclic numbers i.e. 142857, which represents the recurring digit decimal sequence of the reciprocal of 7 (i.e.1/7) in base 10.

Because this number, as the reciprocal of 7, is cyclic in base 10, it will also be cyclic whenever we add 7 onto the number base, i.e. base 17, base 24, base 31 etc.

In fact the simplest earlier example is given in base 3 (i.e. 10 – 7).

So in base 3, 1/7 = .010212 …, where these 6 digits continually recur in regular sequence.

Now when we obtain the difference here of these digits with the next occurrence of this cyclic number (in base 10) i.e. 142857 – 010212 = 132645, we see that all 6 digits from 1-6 repeat just once. And this is always the case.

Furthermore to obtain the unique recurring sequence of digits in the next appropriate number base i.e. base 17, we can simply obtain the sum of 142857 and 132645 (treating the sum of each digit as separate as we are now operating in base 17 rather than base 10).

So 142857 + 132645 = 274E9C.

 

Therefore, we can now see how this readily takes place in the simpler case where our cyclic number contains just 2 digits.

Thus the reciprocal of 3 i.e. 1/3 is first cyclic in base 2 with unique recurring digits 01. It is then, as we have seen, next cyclic in base 5 with unique recurring digits 13. And the difference here is 12 (where the 2 digits from 1 to 2 repeat just once).

This means that to obtain the next cyclic number associated with base 8 we can simply obtain the sum of 13 and 12 i.e. 13 + 12 = 25. And we continue on to obtain the cyclic numbers in further appropriate number bases by successively adding 12. So again as we have seen the cyclic number associated with base 11 is 37 i.e. 25 + 12.

So once again we moved from the cyclic number associated with base 2, to the cyclic number associated with base 5, by adding 12 to 01.

 

This thereby suggests that we should equally be able to move backward in the opposite direction from base 2 through subtracting 12.

Therefore as the relevant number bases keep changing by 3, when we subtract 12 from 01 (defined in base 2) we are thereby now defining this resulting number in a negative number base, i.e. base – 1.

So again when we subtract the two digits, 0 – 1 = – 1; and 1 – 2 = – 1.

So we now have –11  defined with respect to base – 1 (where the first digit 1 now represents 1 * (– 1)1 and the 2nd digit 1 represents 1 * (– 1)0.

This initially might seem very confusing though perhaps it becomes slightly more manageable when we continue to our next number base i.e. base – 4. So we now have –23 defined - as we have seen - in base – 4.


And here is the key to understanding what is meant by a negative number base!

For example in base 10, when one writes 23, this then implies 2 * (10)1 + 3.

Now in base – 10, when one writes –23, this implies 2 * (– 10)1+ 3(– 10)0 

So when we operate in a similar manner in base – 4, we obtain 2 * (– 4)1 + 3(– 4)0

Thus –23 = 2 * (– 4)1 + 3 = – 8 + 3 = –5

So a simpler way of writing –23 in base – 4 is as 23, where we get the negative of the result for –23.

Therefore, 23 in base – 4 = 2 * 41 – 3 = 5.  

Thus, once again in base 4, 23 = (2 * 4) + 3 = 11; however in base – 4, 23 = (2 * 4) – 3 = 5.    

Incidentally going back to our earlier example of base –11 in base – 1, this is now more simply written as 11, which is 1 – 1 = 0 and is the octagonal value for n = 0.

 

So as we have seen the octagonal value (for n = – 1) = 5. And this corresponds to the 2-digit self-generating number 23 (defined in base – 4).

And equally we have the 2-digit self generating numbers in base – 7 as 35,

in base – 10 as 47, in base – 13 as 59 and so on.

And converted to base 10, 35 is (3 * 7) – 5 = 16; 47 = (4 * 10) – 7 = 33; and 59

= (5 * 13) – 9 = 56. And these are the octagonal numbers for n = – 2, – 3, – 4, respectively. And we can continue on indefinitely in this manner with a direct correspondence between 2-digit self generating numbers (defined with respect to negative number bases) and their corresponding octagonal numbers (defined with respect to negative values of n).

So for example 23, representing the first of these numbers defined in base – 4, is thereby self-generating (using the appropriate method of calculation).

Therefore, 32 – 23 = 23.

This is perhaps more easily understood by expressing both sides in base 10 terms.

So 32 = (3 * 4) – 2 = 10; and 23 = (2 * 4) – 3 = 5.

Therefore, 32 = 2 * 23; alternatively, 32 – 23 = 23 (in base – 4).

 

So we will finish now with an extended table that links the octagonal numbers (for the same values of n in the table above) with the corresponding 2-digit self-generating numbers and their respective bases.

…

n = – 4

n = – 3

n = – 2

n = – 1

n = 0

n = 1

n = 2

n = 3

n = 4

…

…

56

33

16

5

0

1

8

21

40

…

…

b = – 13

b = – 10

b = – 7

b = – 4

b = – 1

b = 2

b = 5

b = 8

b = 11

…

…

59

47

35

23

11

01

13

25

37

…

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Fascinating Properties 2

Once again the 2-digit self-generating numbers correspond to the unique recurring digits in the decimal sequence for the reciprocal of 3 (i.e. 1/3). Confining ourselves initially to the positive number bases these correspond to kp – 1, where k = 1,2,3,…, so when p = 3 these therefore occur in the number bases 2, 5, 8, 11, 14, … And the first five of these numbers, as we have seen, are 01, 13, 25, 37 and 49. Now what is fascinating is that when we obtain the square of one of these numbers and subtract from it the corresponding square of the previous number, the result can always be expressed as the difference of two (of the positively defined) octagonal numbers. Why this property may appear surprising is that all these numbers can now refer to their common identity in base 10 terms, whereas previously they were each defined with respect to ever changing distinct number bases! So for example whereas 01 and 13 were previously defined with respect to base 2 and base 5 respectivel...

Fascinating Properties 3

Once again we will start with the table from the preceding entry. Diff of 2-digit squares   Square values Diff result Diff of Octagonal Nos, Diff of Ordinal Rankings 59 2 – 47 2 3481 – 2209 1272 4408 – 3136 .38 th – .32 nd 47 2 – 35 2 2209 – 1225 984 2760 – 1776 .30 th – .24 th 35 2 – 23 2 1225 – 529 696 1496 – 800 .22 nd – .16 th 23 2 – 11 2 529 – 121 408 616 – 208 .14 th   – .8 th 11 2 – 01 2 121– 1 120 120 –  0 .6 th – .0 th   13 2 – 01 2 169 – 1 168 176 –  8 8 th – 2 nd 25 2 – 13 2 625 – 169 456 736 –  280 16 th –...